October 21, 2011 at 9:26am
Drop whatever you're doing and buy tickets to the Rochester Philharmonic Orchestra's Saturday-night program, in which the orchestra will again perform with the Eastman Chorale and the Eastman-Rochester Chorus for Gustav Mahler's Symphony No. 2 in c minor ("the Resurrection Symphony") and Fanny Mendelssohn Hensel's cantata "Hiob" (Job).
Even without the organ called for by the score, Mahler's Resurrection Symphony is huge. On Thursday night the stage was packed with musicians, including five percussionists with no less than two sets of kettle drums, bass drums, gongs, cymbals, and chimes. The first few theater rows were packed with the Eastman-Rochester Chorus. And Arild Remmereit, conductor, swiveled 360 degrees with a diva to his stage left and stage right.
The elements that all clicked into gear, abruptly, as of the fourth movement, made the rest of the symphony gripping and exciting, and so very Mahler. The performance had been going well. Then, the fourth movement opened with mezzo-soprano Ashley Hill. Hill was spellbinding. She sang the German lyrics with such depth of feeling that you could feel what translates as "Man lies in deepest need, Man lives in deepest pain, Oh how I would rather live in heaven."
By the latter half of the fifth movement, when the Eastman-Rochester Chorus and Rebecca Farley Witty, soprano, began to sing, the theater was transformed. At first, the chorus, made up of ESM students and community members, was singing while sitting, their backs to the audience. At just the right juncture, the chorus stood, and at just the right moment, the chorus turned to face the audience. This bit of unusual staging resulted in a natural amplification process that crescendoed the chorus with the soloists and orchestra for a triumphant finale.
For Saturday's second and final performance, the RPO has to take the first three movements to the heights it now knows it can reach in the final two movements. The opening sixteenth notes must become as precise and clean as if they were single notes upon a harpsichord. The transition for every tempo change must be definite. Ritardandos (purposeful slowing down), followed by a tempo (at tempo) should have everyone following the conductor in the first beat. While the ending is an epiphany, the whole symphony is Mahler's expression of the journey of man. From the first notes, the RPO needs to express our common humanity.
Thursday's concert opened beautifully with "Hiob" (Job), a short work by Fanny Mendelssohn Hensel (Felix's sister). Her music is so distinctly female, with warm chord progressions and fullness of sound. It reflects the period of the early 1800's without the detachment and angular structures of many of her contemporaries. This piece was a first for the RPO and part of Remmereit's quest to "make new classics."
"Hiob" included the Eastman Chorale, comprised of students from the Eastman School of Music, who were absolutely fantastic. Their articulation was clear, their pronunciation excellent. The piece was a good match to both the RPO and the Eastman Chorale.
So I suppose that if there is any bit of bad news that I have to convey from tonight's concert, it goes out to Charlie Owens, president and CEO of the RPO, and to the Board of Directors. Big work + big success = big budget. The Mahler alone was an added $40,000, as City earlier reported from its interview with Owens. Judging from the smiles on Remmereit's face tonight as the audience gave a long-sustained standing ovation, I suspect he is already dreaming of the bigger things to come.
The RPO performs the same program Saturday, October 22, at 8 p.m. at Kodak Hall at Eastman Theater. Visit the RPO website for more information.
Thanks for the kind words. Glad you liked the show.
about CONCERT REVIEW: Johnny Winter, Break of Reality, Cowboy Mouth
My best friend bought tickets to concert in rochester ny. The show was cancelled and we didnt...
Yes, My Plastic Sun was amazing. It was great to hear an original band from upstate NY sounding...
about CONCERT REVIEW: My Plastic Sun, Mochester, Sinzibukwud, Audio Influx
As a former Yinzer, I would like to say that Pittsburgh has a "H" on the end of it.
about Party in the Park Lineup Announced: Rusted Root, George Thorogood, 7 Walkers
It was great to see that many people at Sticky Lips to support My Plastic Sun at their debut...
about CONCERT REVIEW: My Plastic Sun, Mochester, Sinzibukwud, Audio Influx
Comments for "CONCERT REVIEW: RPO performs Mahler's Symphony No. 2" (4)
City Newspaper is not responsible for the content of these reviews. City Newspaper reserves the right to remove reviews at their discretion.
Elizabeth said on Oct. 21, 2011 at 10:24am
I so agree with this review. Run, don't walk and get you tickets now! It was a fabulous concert and wonderful night. Thanks to the RPO for proving to us again that we are so fortunate to live in this city.
Peter said on Oct. 21, 2011 at 10:56am
I was a little disappointed. The RPO did not 'digest' this giant symphony very well. Many tempo changes were 'rough'. The orchestra seemed to fall apart in some passages. However, there were many beautiful moments, particularly the fourth movement with gorgeous singing of the mezzo-soprano Ashley Hill.
Brian said on Oct. 21, 2011 at 12:51pm
Loved this review. I have only one small correction: there is an organ being played, it is just unfortunately backstage, I believe due to either the space on stage or the sheer inability to move the organ out there. Elizabeth and Peter said the rest.
Cavsgrrl said on Oct. 22, 2011 at 7:57pm
@Brian
Sorry, there is no organ in Eastman Theatre, not even backstage. What you heard was a synthesizer being played onstage by one of the RPO's keyboard players. The synth sound of an organ was amplified over the sound system to make up for the unfortunate fact that ET lacks an actual pipe organ. It may interest you to know that Kilbourn Hall across the way does actually have a pipe organ; the console is kept in the basement and raised through a stage elevator when it is needed for performances.
Leave A Comment
Respond on Your Blog
Create an Account
or
Login
If you have a City Account you can not only post comments, but you can also respond to articles in your own City Blog. It's just another way to make your voice heard.