Marketview Liquor

Back to Letters

POLITICS: The Catholic Church and contraception

Recommend Article
Total Recommendations (0)

Surely, surely, Mary Anna Towler does not believe what she is saying in "Religion, Politics, and Women's Health" (February 8). Alas, it seems she is in the company of many others with misconceptions of the Catholic Church and the issues at stake here.

The Catholic Church is NOT morally opposed to preventing pregnancy. It believes that sex has two purposes: for the bonding and union of the husband and wife, and for the procreation of the fruit of that love (i.e. children). The Church opposes separating either of these two purposes by artificial means, but is fine with couples spacing their children through Natural Family Planning, which anyone who promotes women's health should support as it gives wonderful insight to a woman's health and fertility. So no woman is forced to bear children when it is not prudent.

Under the HHS mandate, the Catholic Church IS being forced to go against her conscience and provide contraception (the Pill being a double whammy, as it can be an abortifacient, to say nothing of the "morning after pill," which is clearly intended to be used as an abortifacient).

Whether religious institutions are required to provide and pay for contraception directly through their insurance plan, or the insurance companies provide the service, the employers will certainly bear the burden of the cost through increased premiums. While I would like to be able to parse out what my tax dollars go for (I'm no fan of war, either), it is not the same as contracting for services that go against my conscience. Yet that is what religious institutions are being mandated to do.

As for the statement that birth control pills are often used for other medical conditions, there are many drugs that have several uses. Does that add to the argument that they should be provided for free? If so, then what about any other drug used to treat a medical condition? And Ms. Towler neglected to mention the many side effects of the Pill that should give one pause before taking it for any reason!

One of the most glaring inaccuracies came in the section about Planned Parenthood, which has NEVER provided breast cancer screening. They only do referrals, so why Komen gives them so much support in the first place is great cause for investigation.

Mandating an individual or institution to violate their conscience is never the right thing to do. But Ms. Towler got one thing right: "Women's health and women's rights are moral issues, too." Which the Catholic Church fully supports and promotes in her teachings.

SUZANNE STACK, ROCHESTER

Comments for "POLITICS: The Catholic Church and contraception" (2)

City Newspaper is not responsible for the content of these comments. City Newspaper reserves the right to remove comments at their discretion.

User Photo

Mary Jost said on Mar. 09, 2012 at 9:51pm

Great letter, so right on!!!

User Photo

Janet said on Mar. 11, 2012 at 10:19pm

For some people this debate is about a Catholic institution's right to not pay for birth control, but to me the issue goes so much deeper. Limbaugh and local UR Economics Professor Landsburg don't want to pay for women's birth control. I see other issues, see below.
For an economics professor, Professor Landsburg, doesn't seem to be looking very deeply at the economic impact of removing subsidies for birth control coverage for women. Contraceptives prevent unintended pregnancies: pregnancies that would have resulted in unwanted children, abortions, miscarriages and ectopic pregnancies, all of which cost the taxpayer much more than contraceptives. Every dollar spent on family planning and reproductive health (even if completely subsidized by the taxpayer) saves $5.33 that would have been spent on medical services for mother and child. On average American women want 2 children. Without contraceptives the average American woman would have 12 to 15 children in her lifetime. (www.familypact.org) Does Professor Landsburg think that turning the US into a third world country is economically sound?
Perhaps Professor Landsburg agrees with Limbaugh that “all the women at Georgetown University should use aspirin to put between their knees,” as a form of contraception. This would be laughable if it wasn’t so cruel when you know the hard facts:
The National College Women Sexual Victimization Study estimated that between 1 in 4 to 1 in 5 college women experience completed or attempted rape during their college years Every two minutes, somewhere in America, someone is sexually assaulted. Men perpetrate the majority of violent acts against women. In the United States, 1.5 million women are raped and/or physically assaulted by an intimate partner every year. (US Department of Justice).
What is so twisted is that the words of Limbaugh (for decades) and Landsburg (locally), besides the hypocrisy, create a climate of misogyny that encourages violence toward women. Their words give public credence and encouragement to demonizing, demeaning women.
Think I’m overreacting? I have worked in the domestic violence field for 25 years. Victims tell me all the time that violence starts with demeaning, intimidating words, words that are heard on radio shows like Limbaugh’s every day and influence weak-minded, unthinking men.
In a survey of domestic violence programs in New York State on 9/15/2011 (with 74% reporting, so it is underreported), 5021 victims of domestic violence sought help on JUST ONE DAY , with 449 turned away due to lack of services. This is a big problem! And I can tell you from experience of interviewing thousands of women in Monroe County over the last 25 years, that sexual abuse, including rape occurs regularly among these women. Without birth control, and yes, that frequently means subsidized birth control, women in these situations are forced to have baby after baby, putting even more burden on Professor Landsburg’s wallet. They might not think their words denote misogyny, but they do and they won’t be tolerated. Professor Landsburg, in particular, should be ashamed.

Leave A Comment

(This will not be published)

(Optional)

Respond on Your Blog

If you have a City Account you can not only post comments, but you can also respond to articles in your own City Blog. It's just another way to make your voice heard.